Should I end our relationship? Need advice soon.. so hurt and confused

[kreestar]

Where do I begin. My boyfriend had a girl named starsha call him. He said he didn't know who it was. He didnt act dishonest or anything, he just flat out said he didn't know, maybe someone from west plains. Anyway. Sunday I found a number with the name Star in his phone. Well. He hasn't had that phone very long so the number was in their recently, but he said again he didn't know who it was and that it may have been put there at project graduation. Well. I thought everything was worked out and that I was okay. He wouldn't cheat, and has never lied to me before. He's been cheated on a lot so I know he wouldn't do this.
Last night I found a number on his computer desk that had the same area code as this starsha cell phone. Well we called it and guess who it was. Nathaniel had told me he didn't know who that number was and that maybe his parents gave it to him. Well. Nathaiel asked her if she was trying to get ahold of him and him mouthed to me that they didn't know each other. Well I talked to her then. She told me they had met at state and that she wanted to keep in touch with some of the people. She said you guys are together right? and said that she had a boyfriend and that she hoped everything worked out. Well. Nathaniel consistently denied having an acutally conversation with the girl, (she said they talked a couple times on the phone) and he said that "hi bye" could consist of a conversation. I found the girl on xanga and she doesn't look like a hussy or anything like that and she does have a boyfriend. Plus she lives halfway across the state so I know nothing is going on. I just want to know why Nathaniel lied about not knowing her. He either did forget who she was because he has other things on his mind (graduation, work, prom, me, or he didn't say anything and lied because he didn't want me to get jealous. or he just didn't want me to know and he's lying constantly. He kept saying if you love me you would trust me (we just had an issue with me and his email. I do have trust issues and this crap didnt help one bit. But if he cant tell me whats going on then we have a problem) and I almost broke up with him, but my heart kept telling me how much I love him and that I do trust him. But my head was saying run. This girl is not a threat. The threat is in if he is lying, or if he will lie about other things. I want to trust him and forget about this, but I can't get it out of my head that it won't be the last time.

I should add that Nathaniel is not a player. He's not one of those guys that every girl is after. He's not very tall and not muscular. I love him. He's perfect for me. The reason I'm saying this is that he's not the kind to go out and cheat or party or hang around slinky girls. I believe that theyre talks were friendship, if anything and that he loves me. I just need advice on what I should do. He said whatever I choose to do he'd be there waiting. I choose to stay with him, but obviously, I still have questions on my mind.
Edit/Delete Message

[vashti]

UGH!!! Why did you post this in THREE forums???

[bluestrattos]

personally, i don't see a trust relationship if you keep checking his cell phone, computer and emails. I'm sorry if i misunderstood your post.

If he's such a good fella, i probably think i lie to avoid having you worried about that girl, the intention was good, but the result not so good.

Anyway, don't end your relationship for that. If what happened it's only what you said, i don't see a reason to end your relation with nathaniel. Just learn to trust, but don't be naive.

Good luck!

[Chris-B]

sounds like he spoke to her on the phone as friends, but lied to you about it as he thought you will get very angry if he told you, as you have trust problems.

dont break up over it, its not worth it, just talk to the guy and say theres no harm done, but he must tell you about these things in the future.