I think it's like milk. If you grow up drinking skim milk, you'll hate the taste of 2% milk. If you're used to whole milk, you'll hate 1% milk.
If you're used to cut, you'll think uncut is weird and vice versa. Most of the people who prefer uncut are not American, it seems; since it's more common outside the US, that's what you're used to seeing. To reassure the people who are appalled at the idea of "mutilating" a baby boy, you'll never meet a circumcised man who's upset about it. He was a baby when it happened, he doesn't remember it, and it doesn't affect his life in the slightest.