1. If she won't overcome her aversion to semen, or even try, what's going to happen when you 2 get married and can't decide on what house to buy, or how many kids to have? Sounds like she won't be able to compromise because no one has made her try something new before. That's one red flag I see.
2. Instead of a whole handful of lube (some of which are a bit "greasy" feeling) try putting it on one of her fingers, and start with that. Surely you might have one sensitive area that one of her fingers could satisfy?
Yes, the flavored lubes are great. I especially like one that tastes like cherry sweettarts. I mean, wow. Yummy. Here it is:
[url=http://www.amazon.com/TLC-Tarts-Lube-Cherry-Pillow/dp/B001IDL0L6]Amazon.com: TLC Sex Tarts Lube, Cherry Pop, 6 Cc (6 Ml), Pillow Pack: Health & Personal Care[/url]
3. I can also see her as being very averse to trying new sex things. You have to decide if you can put up with a "vanilla" girlfriend, or you really, truly need someone to get a bit more freaky. You really need to be honest with yourself on this one, as it can cause a lot of tension and fights.
I have a long time interest in psychology, specializing in relationship dynamics for 30 years.
(Please note, we give the best advice we can based on the information given in a post. For better advice, please include the age of all romantic partners.)